By Mike McKenna, Headmaster
Four out of my five children told me at one time or another that they hated school. Some begged me for weeks—even months—on end to put them in another school. I share that not to discourage you, but to let you know that if your child has ever said those words to you, I feel your pain.
But I want to begin with someone else's daughter, a young woman named Rose.
Years ago, Rose was a tenth grader at my school. One day, she was sent to my office for a relatively minor infraction. She was clearly unhappy, so I asked her what was wrong. Her answer was memorable: "I hate this school, Mr. McKenna. I've hated every day of my life in this school."
I had a suspicion that Rose didn't like school. And I didn't pretend otherwise. But I also knew that Rose was a child.
Today, Rose leads global sales for a medical technology firm.
What strikes me about Rose isn't simply that she changed her mind about school. It's what she came to value.
As a college student, Rose had the self-assurance to pursue an internship in New York City, the humility to read a book someone recommended to her that helped shape her career trajectory, and the self-awareness to recognize her own strengths. As an adult at the top of her field, she recognizes that her school years helped develop her ability to speak publicly, take on unfamiliar challenges with courage and gusto, engage strangers with confidence, challenge ideas with decorum, read critically, and organize her work.
The very experience she once resented became part of the preparation she now appreciates. Rose will tell you today that she attributes a large part of the formation of those qualities to her time in classical Christian education.
Her story reminds us of something important: Children don't always have the perspective to recognize what is shaping them.
Children See Things Differently
The Apostle Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 13:11, "When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child."
Children really do see things differently. Their feelings are genuine, but their judgment is still developing. That means we mustn't scorn their feelings, but neither should we give their feelings uncritical sympathy. Feelings can be deceptive.
Education is about more than acquiring knowledge or preparing for the next stage of life. At Mars Hill Academy, we seek to cultivate wisdom and virtue, helping students learn to recognize and love what is true, good, and beautiful; grow in wisdom and discernment; develop habits of diligence, humility, and perseverance; and love God and serve their neighbors.
The challenges of school are not separate from this work. They are often opportunities for it.
So what should we do when our child comes home and announces, "I hate school"?
Our first response shouldn't be dismissal or a lecture. It should be a question: "Tell me what happened."
Perhaps there is a difficult assignment. Perhaps a friend has been unkind. Perhaps a teacher disappointed your child. Perhaps there is genuine anxiety that adults should address. We can't know until we listen.
Listen without immediately defending the school, but also without immediately confirming your child's concern. Ask yourself: Is this a hard day, a recurring difficulty, or a real danger? Does my child need comfort, coaching, correction, or cover?
As Christian parents, we must be willing to hear hard things about our children and their perceptions. But loving a child doesn't mean taking every concern and disappointment as something we must fix for them. Taking a child seriously doesn't mean treating every first reaction as the final verdict.
Here are six lessons I believe we need to keep in mind.
Six Lessons for Parents
1. We Are Raising Sturdy Adults
Our purpose isn't simply to produce children who are comfortable today. We are raising men and women who can meet the challenges of tomorrow.
Adults do difficult things because those things are right, necessary, or loving. We get up when we are tired. We finish work we'd rather avoid. We keep promises when keeping them costs us. We care for others when we're exhausted.
These qualities don't suddenly appear on your child's twenty-first birthday. They're cultivated.
A demanding assignment, a challenging course, or a speech before classmates can be a modest but meaningful opportunity to practice faithfulness.
I would say to a child: "I know this is hard. I also believe you can grow through hard things. I'm not asking you to enjoy every moment. I'm asking you to learn to meet your responsibilities with courage."
Sturdiness is not hardness of heart. It is strength joined to humility, compassion, and self-control.
2. You Won't Always Think as You Think Today
One of the hardest truths to communicate to a teenager is this: Your present perspective is not the whole picture.
I remember Rose's emphatic words: "I have hated every day in this school!" I also know the woman she became.
What changed? Experience, maturity, perspective, and the passage of time.
Parents possess a vantage point that children simply don't yet have. That isn't because parents are infallible; we're not. It's because we've lived through chapters our children haven't.
Sometimes we have to say, "I understand that you can't see the value of this right now. I'm asking you to trust my judgment."
And then we should expect them to do just that, even—especially—when it's hard.
Letting children decide who has access to their hearts, minds, and souls at 13, 14, 15, or 16 is incomprehensible to me. Parents have a responsibility to help guide those decisions, even when our children don't yet understand the reasons behind them.
3. School Is a Training Ground
A school is not merely a place where students acquire facts. It is a community in which habits are formed and loves are shaped.
A difficult paper teaches more than writing. It may teach patience, planning, revision, and the humility to accept correction.
A test teaches more than recall. It can teach preparation, composure, and how to recover from disappointment.
A speech teaches more than rhetoric. It teaches a young person to stand up, speak clearly, and face the discomfort of being seen.
Even ordinary social friction can become an occasion to practice forgiveness, courage, wisdom, and longsuffering.
None of this means that every difficulty is good or that every teacher handles every situation perfectly. It means that the ordinary challenges of school can be used by the Lord to shape us into the people He has for us to be.
Instead of asking, "How can I get out of this?" we have to teach our children to ask instead, "What is the faithful next step?"
4. As Your Parent, I'm More Concerned with Your Holiness Than Your Happiness
A child will hear this as, "You don't care!" But of course, we do.
The important thing for parents and teachers to help our children understand is this: If you want happiness without holiness, you want what never has been, nor ever will be. If you pursue holiness before happiness, eventually you'll have both.
Proverbs 28:14 says, "Happy is the man that feareth always: but he that hardeneth his heart shall fall into mischief."
Our job as parents is to teach our children to pursue the fear of the Lord first, so that they find joy and true happiness later.
We want our children to be happy. But we want something far greater for them than a life in which they are always comfortable, entertained, or pleased with their circumstances. We want them to become men and women who love God, walk in His ways, and find their joy in Him.
5. Adult Responsibilities Are Heavier
I don't say this to belittle the burdens of childhood. A lonely lunch table can feel enormous to a thirteen-year-old. A failed exam can be deeply discouraging. We should remember what those experiences felt like.
But adulthood brings responsibilities that are often heavier: a demanding boss, a mortgage payment, a sick child, a strained marriage, a family member who needs care, and obligations that don't disappear because we are unhappy.
We can't flee every difficult conversation or abandon every duty when it becomes uncomfortable.
School offers a relatively sheltered setting in which children can begin learning to persevere, seek help, make amends, and try again.
Our task is not to throw them into the deep end and tell them to swim. It is to teach them to swim while we are still nearby.
6. Remember Why You Chose Mars Hill in the First Place
There is one more lesson I especially want to leave with you as parents: Remember why you chose Mars Hill Academy in the first place.
You didn't come here because you expected every day to be easy or every assignment to be pleasant. You came because you believe a classical Christian education forms the mind, the character, and the affections of your child, and because you want that formation to take place within a community committed to Christ.
Children look to their parents not only for comfort but also for conviction.
If every difficult week reopens the question of whether your family belongs at Mars Hill, your child may understandably keep making the case for leaving. When a parent wavers and vacillates, a child can interpret that uncertainty as an invitation to press the appeal again and again.
But when parents communicate a calm, united, and thoughtful commitment, children are more likely to settle in. They need not like every aspect of school to know that their parents believe in its purpose.
I'm not asking you to pretend that Mars Hill is perfect or to refuse to hear legitimate concerns. A strong commitment is not blind loyalty. It means that we address problems honestly, work with teachers and administrators, and make considered decisions as adults—not decisions driven by the emotion of a particularly difficult Tuesday or a difficult November.
Let your child see that your convictions are firm enough to withstand discomfort.
You might say: "We chose Mars Hill for good reasons, and those reasons haven't disappeared because this week is hard. We will listen to you, we will help you, and we will take real problems seriously. But we're not going to reconsider our family's educational commitments every time school becomes difficult."
That isn't harshness. It is loving steadiness.
An Important Qualification: Perseverance Is Not Passivity
Now I want to be very clear. Perseverance isn't the same thing as passivity.
If a child is showing signs of serious emotional distress, the proper adult response might not be, "Toughen up." We intervene. We investigate. We protect. We work with teachers and administrators.
There is a difference between a challenge that forms character and a harmful situation that requires correction.
Nor should we assume that a child who struggles academically simply lacks grit. Sometimes the child needs instruction, accommodation, support, or a different approach.
Wisdom means discerning the difference. Courage sometimes means staying the course; sometimes it means speaking up and changing what is wrong.
A Practical Response: Listen, Discern, Encourage, Partner
So what should you say tonight if your son or daughter announces, "I hate school"?
Try this:
"I'm sorry today was so hard. Tell me what happened."
Listen carefully. Then ask:
"What part of this can you change? What part do you need help with? What would a wise next step look like?"
If the situation is ordinary difficulty, encourage persistence and help make a plan. If the situation is harmful, act to make it safe. If a teacher needs to be involved, reach out as a partner, not as a prosecutor. You might say, "We want to understand what's happening and help you respond well."
Above all, communicate two things at once:
"I love you, and I will help you."
And:
"I believe you can grow in the face of difficulty."
Children need both assurance and expectation.
We Are Preparing Them for More Than School
Rose couldn't see in tenth grade what she would see years later. Most of our children can't see that far either.
That's why God has given them parents and teachers: adults who can love them in the present while preparing them for a future they can't possibly imagine.
We don't promise them a painless education or a painless life. We promise to walk with them, to tell them the truth, to correct what is wrong, and to help them become wise, virtuous, and faithful adults.
The next time your child says, "I hate school," don't panic, and don't dismiss the complaint. Listen. Discern. Encourage. Partner.
And remember: We are not merely trying to get them through school.
In John Milton's epic poem Paradise Lost, Satan delivers the famous line: "The mind is its own place, and in itself, can make a Heav'n of Hell, a Hell of Heav'n."
Our children are still children. Their affections are still being shaped, and their judgments are far from final. We shouldn't be too quick to let their current perceptions be the deciding factor in the important matter of providing an education that shapes their souls and trains their affections.
That is the work before us as parents and educators. And it is work worth persevering in.